Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
Washington DC Business Lawyer
~ Washington DC Business Law Attorneys ~

Dupont Circle Restaurant Owner Settles Non-Compete Dispute with Chef


Many employers ask the employees they hire for highly specialized and skilled positions to sign non-compete agreements when they begin their employment.  The non-compete agreements, or even non-compete clauses in employment contracts, often restrict the employee from working for a competitor or the employer, or establishing a new business in direct competition with the employer, for a certain period of time after the employee stops working for the employer.  When disputes arise in connection to non-compete clauses, the courts must decide whether the clause is fair or whether the employer is unjustly restricting the former employee’s employment options.  In the restaurant industry, for example, it would be unconscionable to make a chef sign a non-compete agreement forbidding him ever to work in a restaurant again if he quits working for you.  If you are involved in a dispute over a non-compete agreement, contact a Washington DC business litigation lawyer.

Mirabelle and Annabelle Settle Their Dispute Over a Non-Compete Agreement

Mirabelle is a fine dining restaurant in the Dupont Circle neighborhood of Washington DC; its owner is Hakan Ilhan, and the restaurant styles itself as serving global French cuisine.  Annabelle, another fine dining restaurant located several blocks away from Mirabelle, belongs to Ashok Bajaj and describes its cuisine as modern American.  When Frank Ruta was hired as a chef for Mirabelle, he signed a non-compete agreement promising that, if he quit working at Mirabelle, he could not accept a job in a similar restaurant within a ten-mile radius until two years after he had stopped working at Mirabelle.  The agreement also stipulated that Ruta was not allowed to recruit Mirabelle staff or solicit Mirabelle customers to his new restaurant until two years after his employment with Mirabelle ended.

In July 2018, Ruta was laid off from Mirabelle, as was pastry chef Aggie Chin.  Shortly thereafter, Ruta applied for a job at Annabelle and began working there.  After Ruta attempted to recruit several employees from Mirabelle, Ilhan sued Ruta, alleging that Ruta violated the non-compete agreement by working for a restaurant so nearby and with such a similar name within months of leaving Mirabelle.  Ruta responded that the non-compete agreement would only apply if he voluntarily quit working for Mirabelle.  Since it was Ilhan who chose to terminate Ruta’s employment, Ruta should not have to abide by the terms of the non-compete agreement.  The parties settled their dispute in February 2020, without any money changing hands.  In an interview with the Washingtonian, Ilhan said that he had never intended to stop Ruta from getting another job after firing him; the real issue was Ruta’s attempts to recruit employees and customers to Annabelle from the kitchen and dining room of Mirabelle.  He said that he was glad the dispute has been resolved.

Let Us Help You Today

Especially in such tough economic times, you may need a Washington DC business litigation attorney to help you resolve disputes with former business partners, employees, or co-workers.  Contact Tobin O’Connor Concino P.C. for help today.




Facebook Twitter LinkedIn